Your CAC crisis isn't unique

In partnership with

This Week's Reality Check

• Your CAC crisis isn't imagined, fresh data proves it's structural

• Platform costs doubled while conversion rates stagnated

• Trade disruption creates the biggest repositioning window in years

• Smart operators are diversifying now, before alternatives saturate

Your CAC Crisis Is Real (And Getting Worse)

The Problem: Platform Economics Broke Your Growth Model

Why what got you to $5M won't get you to $15M

If you're reading this feeling like your marketing dollars just... evaporate, you're experiencing something very real and very measurable. The platforms changed the game while you were playing it.

The brutal data:

• Facebook CPMs rose 90% between 2018-2019, another 37% in Q1 2022

• Instagram CPMs up 27% in the same period

• iOS 14.5 killed 75% of attribution tracking

• Customer acquisition costs doubled industry-wide 2019-2023

But here's what separates this from typical "advertising is expensive" complaints: The fundamental economics shifted. 

You're not just paying more for the same results. You're paying more for worse results while competing against bigger players with deeper pockets.

Fresh agency intelligence from this week confirms what you're feeling: existing Meta advertisers are seeing performance, but they're the ones who adapted to the new AI tools.

Everyone else is watching efficiency decline while costs climb.

The Agitation: Why This Gets Worse Before It Gets Better

Meta's Q2 numbers tell the real story. Yes, they posted 22% revenue growth driven by eCommerce. But that growth came from AI-enabled advertisers using Advantage+ and new attribution models. Translation: if you're not using their latest tools, you're competing at a massive disadvantage on an already expensive platform.

Trade Desk just proved platform costs are going structural. Their Kokai rollout doubled programmatic CPMs overnight. Agencies report paying 2x previous rates for the same inventory. This isn't a glitch—it's the new baseline.

Reddit's breakthrough moment makes the timing worse. Their Q2 success (55% of agency partners now exceeding performance goals) means the smart money is already moving. Early-mover advantage on alternative platforms disappears fast when performance data gets this good.

Trump's tariffs hit next week, forcing immediate cost decisions. While everyone else scrambles with pricing and margins, the window for strategic repositioning closes daily.

The Solutions: Three Moves That Actually Work

1. Platform Diversification (Before It's Too Late)

Reddit's mid-funnel attribution breakthrough isn't just interesting, it's actionable.

Conversation Ads finally solved the attribution gap that kept performance marketers skeptical.

Pinterest Performance+ adoption jumped from <10% to >25% of agency spend in one quarter because it works.

The play: Test Reddit and Pinterest now while CPMs remain 30% below Meta levels. The agencies we track are already advocating these platforms to new clients based on recent performance data.

2. Attribution Independence (Stop Flying Blind)

Meta's AI tools only work if you feed them clean data. With Google's cookiepocalypse still coming, first-party attribution systems aren't optional anymore, they're survival tools.

Build customer data platforms that track lifetime value, not just conversions. The brands breaking through plateaus know which channels drive repeat buyers, not just first purchases.

3. Trade Disruption Positioning (Turn Crisis Into Advantage)

Trump's 35% Canadian tariffs and de minimis changes create repositioning opportunities, not just cost problems. Digital-first U.S. market strategies bypass physical trade restrictions entirely. "Buy Canadian" positioning delivers pricing power AND authenticity premium simultaneously.

The smart play: Redirect budgets into U.S. retail media (Amazon, Instacart, Walmart Connect) while competitors absorb tariff costs. Capture American demand without moving physical goods.

What's Working Right Now

Reddit Conversation Ads: Mid-funnel attribution that actually tracks Pinterest Performance+: 55% of partners exceeding previous benchmarks
Amazon DSP: Lower take rates while Trade Desk doubles pricing Canadian brand positioning: Competitive advantage disguised as trade pressure

What's failing: Single-platform optimization, attribution-dependent campaigns, reactive tariff responses, premium programmatic without alternatives.

The Bottom Line

Your CAC crisis isn't a marketing problem, it's an economics problem that requires strategic solutions, not optimization tactics.

The platforms got more expensive and less effective simultaneously. That's not your fault, but adapting to it is your responsibility.

The founders breaking through aren't better marketers. They're faster decision-makers who diversified before their current channels became uneconomical.

The question: Will you diversify while alternatives still offer efficiency advantages, or after your current channels price you out?

The Ad Insider is intelligence for founders who refuse to stay stuck
Ready to break through? [Get your growth audit →]

Marketing ideas for marketers who hate boring

The best marketing ideas come from marketers who live it.

That’s what this newsletter delivers.

The Marketing Millennials is a look inside what’s working right now for other marketers. No theory. No fluff. Just real insights and ideas you can actually use—from marketers who’ve been there, done that, and are sharing the playbook.

Every newsletter is written by Daniel Murray, a marketer obsessed with what goes into great marketing. Expect fresh takes, hot topics, and the kind of stuff you’ll want to steal for your next campaign.

Because marketing shouldn’t feel like guesswork. And you shouldn’t have to dig for the good stuff.

Subscribe Free